Speech Notes for College/HRG News conference
Howard Johnson Hotel, Edmonton, Alberta
August 1998
Good morning and welcome. My name is Audrey Cormack. Im president of the
Alberta Federation of Labour and Ive been chosen as one of three people to speak on
behalf of our Medicare Coalition.
The coalition is a loose association of individuals and organizations who have been
meeting periodically over the past several months to discuss concerns about health care in
Alberta.
With me today are Liz Reid, from the group Friends of Medicare, and Phyllis Matousek,
from the Seniors Action Liaison Team.
This morning, each of us will speak for two or three minutes and explain why weve
called this news conference. Following that, well open the floor for questions.
But first, Id like to Ill kick things off by giving a little bit of
background.
As many of you already know, a private, for-profit health care facility was opened was
opened in Calgary last Fall the first in Canada since Medicare was introduced. The
hospital is located in the old Salvation Army Grace Hospital and is operated by a company
called the Health Resources Group HRG for short.
So far, HRG has been restricted in the kind of services they can offer. They can do
some dental surgery, some cosmetic surgery and theyve also been doing some rehab
work. But they havent been allowed to do procedures that require overnight stays.
But HRG isnt satisfied with their share of the pie they want the right to
keep patients overnight so they can divert even more patients away from the public system.
Today and tomorrow, the College of Physicians and Surgeons will be considering a formal
request from HRG regarding overnight stays. Last December, the College refused HRG when
they made the same request. But since that time, HRG has been busy lobbying members of the
College. Theyve paid for legal opnions saying that saying the College has no legal
right to refuse HRGs request.
As a result of all the lobbying and pressure from HRG, the College has agreed to
reconsider the request for overnight stays.
All of us at the AFL and in the Medicare Coalition are extremely concerned about this
issue. Early next month an important decision is going to be made on this issue a
decision that may determine the future of HRG and private health care in Alberta. HRG is
going to be asking If the College approves HRGs request it will be a serious blow to
Medicare. It will basically turn the HRG facility at the Grace into a full-fledged private
hospital which will compete with public hospitals for already scarce funding.
So were asking you and members of your union to get involved. Wed like you
to write or call members of the College. Tell them to stand by their original decision.
Tell them to say "No" to more private health care.
Were also encouraging people to attend the Colleges October 2 meeting,
which is being held in Calgary at the Palliser Hotel (Canadian Pacific Room). Its
open to the public and the discussion on HRG is scheduled to start at 8:30 a.m.
Wed like to see as many people at the meeting as possible. What we want to do is
fill the room and make it clear to the College that the public opposes HRG and the
expansion of private health care in Alberta.
Thanks for taking the time to consider this request. If you do write letters, please
fax them to individual College members directly (see attached fax list). I look forward to
seeing you at the Palliser bright and early on October 2!
Urge the Council to stand by its original
decision: This will not be the first time the College has addressed the HRGs
plans to expand private health care in Alberta. In December 1997, HRG also requested
permission to offer medical procedures that require overnight stays. At the time, the
College rejected the request on the grounds that an expanded private hospital would not be
in the public interest. In your letter, congratulate the College for standing up in
defense of Medicare and remind them that HRG still poses a threat. Rejecting
HRGs application for overnight stays was the right thing to do last year and
it still is.
Urge the Council not to be intimidated by veiled threats from HRG and its lawyers:
Since the College rejected HRGs request last year, the company has hired lawyers to
review the decision. HRGs lawyers are now saying that the College overstepped its
authority by refusing to allow overnight stays. They have also suggested that individual
college members might become the subjects of lawsuits for "interfering" with
HRGs business plans. But not everyone agrees with the way HRGs lawyers have
interpreted the law. A legal opinion commissioned by the New Democrats shows that the
College clearly has the right to take actions in "defense of the public good."
In your letter to College members, urge them not to be intimidated by the college. Remind
them that HRG is simply motivated by a desire to improve its profits. The Colleges
job is to protect the public interest and that means saying "no" to HRG.
Remind them why HRG poses a threat: The debate over HRG has become bogged down in
legal arguments and counter arguments. In your letter, remind members of the College why
they rejected HRGs request in the first place. Remind them that an expanded HRG
hospital will siphon scarce resources away from our already under-funded public hospitals.
Remind them that an expanded HRG hospital would be the first step towards a two-tier
health system a system that would provide high quality care to the wealthy and a
lower, inadequate standard of care to everyone else.
|