TNT_Logo_3s.gif (5322 bytes) 

TNT's Homepage
TNT Links
Photo Gallery
Hiking Puzzles
Other Stuff
Christmas Songs

Solution to 12 Balls & a Scale

Once again, Brian has supplied a clever solution.  Gotta love this guy.

Label the balls A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, I, J, K, L.  We refer to the 3 weighings as #1, #2 and #3.  "A vs B" means A is on the left of the scale, B on the right; order matters.

Once the different ball has been found, it's relative mass may be found by looking at any weighing where it was on the scale. 

WEIGHING #1:  ABCD vs EFGH

IF THIS BALANCES (A-H are "neutral").  Go to weighing #2.a

WEIGHING #2.a:  IJ vs KA 

IF THIS BALANCES, weigh L vs A.  L is either lighter or heavier as indicated by this weighing.

OTHERWISE, weigh I vs J.  If this balances, K is different.  If it doesn't balance, but goes the same  way as weighing #2, then I is different.  If it goes the opposite way, J is different. 

OTHERWISE (I-L are "neutral").  Go to weighing #2.b

WEIGHING #2.b:  ABE vs CFI

IF OPPOSITE to weighing #1, C or E are different.  Weigh C vs I to determine the result.  If this balances, E is different.  Otherwise C is different. 

IF weighing #2.b is the SAME as weighing #1, weigh A vs B (weighing #3.a).  
If weighing #3.a balances, then F is different.    
If weighing #3.a is the same as #1 and #2.b, then A is different.  
If weighing #3.a goes the opposite way from #1 and #2.b, then B is different. 

IF weighing #2.b BALANCES, weigh G vs H (weighing #3.b).  
If weighing #3.b balances, then D is different.
If weighing #3.b is the same as #1, then H is different.  Otherwise G is different. 

Thanks Bri!

Back

 

This page was updated on February 01, 2004
Comments
or suggestions:admin28@timntoni.com