TNT_Logo_3s.gif (5322 bytes) 

TNT's Homepage
TNT Links
Photo Gallery
Hiking Puzzles
Other Stuff
Christmas Songs

Solution to Monty's Revenge Puzzle

Okay, this one's a bit tough to explain.  There certainly are many ways to show the answer.

The probability that Chris chose the right door to start with is 1/3.

Therefore, the probability that one of the other two doors holds the prize (the Kamei puzzles) is 2/3.

However, once one of these doors is open, the probability that the remaining, un-chosen door, contains the prize must be 2/3.

So, you now have the original door, with 1/3 odds, vs. the other door, with 2/3 odds.  Therefore, its much better to switch!

Don't believe us?  This problem is so famous in the mathematics community there are many web-sites devoted to it:

bulletWWW Tackles the Monty Hall Problem (a list of sites dedicated to the problem)
bulletMonty Hall Dilemma contains a simulation of the problem

If you don't like the solution to this problem, please don't e-mail us!  Go e-mail one of those other websites!

Back

 

This page was updated on February 01, 2004
Comments
or suggestions:admin28@timntoni.com